Is the Fed Making a Mistake? The Risks of Pushing Interest Rates Higher

The Federal Reserve’s inclination toward additional interest-rate increases is facing growing criticism from market experts who believe policymakers may be overlooking recent changes in inflation trends. Falling prices for gasoline, crude oil and several other commodities suggest that inflationary pressures could be easing, potentially making further monetary tightening unnecessary.

Analysts argue that the Fed is placing too much importance on backward-looking indicators, including the Consumer Price Index (CPI) and Producer Price Index (PPI). These reports reflect price movements from the previous month and may not accurately represent the latest developments in financial and commodity markets.

By comparison, real-time indicators such as gasoline futures, refining margins and retail fuel prices are showing signs of declining inflationary pressure.

“Inflation is a lagging indicator. It tells you what you paid last month. The crack spread is a leading indicator. It tells you what you’ll pay next month. One says inflation is too high. The other says it’s already falling. The Fed is listening to the first one. It’s about to hike into falling prices at the pump,” said Thierry Borgeat, co-founder and chief investment officer of Arvy, a Zurich-based asset management company regulated by Swiss financial watchdog FINMA.

The prospect of additional rate increases is also creating uncertainty across cryptocurrency markets, particularly for Bitcoin. Higher interest rates typically raise borrowing costs and reduce demand for riskier investments.

Recent statements from Federal Reserve officials and the minutes of the October policy meeting have strengthened expectations that borrowing costs could rise further.

According to the minutes released Wednesday, almost all participants believed additional increases in the federal funds rate could be appropriate in the coming months. Policymakers pointed to their expectations for inflation and employment, emphasizing the need to bring inflation back to the Fed’s 2% target.

Two officials indicated that a December increase larger than 25 basis points could be necessary if incoming inflation figures were unfavorable. A basis point represents 0.01 percentage point, meaning a 25-basis-point adjustment equals a quarter of a percentage point.

Fed Governor Christopher Waller also voiced support for a 50-basis-point increase in December during an appearance on CNBC Wednesday. This would represent twice the size of the central bank’s typical rate adjustment.

Governor Michael Barr similarly suggested that higher borrowing costs could be necessary, while San Francisco Fed President Mary Daly called for a more cautious approach.

Such policy decisions could weigh on Bitcoin and other risk assets by making financing more expensive and reducing the amount of capital investors are willing to allocate to volatile markets.

However, market analysts argue that the Fed’s assessment may be relying too heavily on October’s CPI and PPI reports. While those figures showed price pressures spreading across everyday products and services, they do not capture the latest decline in energy prices and other commodities.

Energy costs have been a significant source of inflation since the Iran war began in early March.

Gasoline market signals challenge the Fed’s inflation outlook

The latest movements in refining margins provide another indication that inflation could be slowing.

The crack spread measures the profit refiners generate by processing crude oil into products such as gasoline and diesel. It represents the difference between the price of crude oil and the market value of the refined fuels.

One of the industry’s most closely followed benchmarks is the 3-2-1 crack spread. The calculation assumes that three barrels of crude oil produce two barrels of gasoline and one barrel of diesel.

A declining spread generally indicates that gasoline and diesel prices are weakening faster than crude oil prices. This trend can eventually translate into lower prices for consumers.

Data shared by James E. Thorne, chief market strategist at Wellington Altus, showed that the 3-2-1 crack spread had contracted 36% over the previous six weeks.

The measure dropped from $65.56 per barrel to $41.90 as of Wednesday, indicating a substantial reduction in refining profitability.

Thorne attributed the decline to growing fuel supplies after refiners increased production during a period of unusually strong margins. The resulting increase in output has put pressure on gasoline and diesel prices.

He also highlighted the weakness in wholesale RBOB gasoline futures, which have declined approximately 20%, while retail gasoline prices have moved toward $3.78 per gallon.

RBOB futures represent wholesale gasoline prices traded on the NYMEX. The contracts fell 11.1% and 6.1% over the last two completed weeks, producing a combined decline of approximately 16.5%.

Another 4.4% drop this week has pushed the three-week decline close to 20%. CoinDesk’s analysis of TradingView data indicates that this is the largest three-week decrease since March 2020.

The decline is already reaching retail markets. AAA reported that the average U.S. price of regular gasoline stood at $3.75 per gallon on Thursday.

This represents a 12.8% decrease over the past month and a 4.9% decline compared with the previous week. However, gasoline prices remain approximately 22% higher than their level a year ago.

Thorne believes consumers could see additional savings as wholesale price reductions gradually pass through to gas stations.

He estimated that each 10-cent decline in gasoline prices could reduce headline CPI by around nine basis points. He also suggested that November could deliver a negative headline inflation reading, while the March year-over-year comparison would remove the earlier war-related energy price increase.

In his assessment, the latest decline reflects an oversupply of fuel rather than weakening demand. Falling energy prices are therefore already contributing to the Fed’s inflation objectives, potentially reducing the need for further rate increases.

Commodity markets experience widespread declines

The weakness in energy markets has extended into several other commodity sectors, reinforcing the argument that inflationary pressures may be moderating.

Ryan Detrick, chief market strategist at Carson Investment Research, reviewed the performance of commodity-focused exchange-traded funds through Wednesday’s closing session. These funds generally track futures contracts, so their performance can differ from actual spot market prices.

Gasoline ETF UGA has fallen 20.9% since the beginning of November. The United States crude oil fund (USO) has declined 19.4%, while the Brent crude ETF (BNO) has recorded an 18.7% loss.

The broader commodity market has also weakened. Diversified commodity funds have dropped approximately 12%, while copper ETF CPER has declined 12.5%.

Agricultural products have followed a similar trend. Wheat ETF WEAT has lost 4.6%, while corn ETF CORN has fallen 2.7%. Gold ETF GLD has also recorded a 4.1% decline.

Natural gas remains the exception, posting a 16.9% gain this month.

The broad-based sell-off has prompted some investors to question the reasoning behind the Fed’s increasingly aggressive interest-rate messaging.

James Lavish, co-managing partner of Bitcoin Opportunity Fund, expressed doubts about the possibility of a 50-basis-point increase in December, given the visible reduction in energy-related inflation pressures.

He suggested that the central bank’s hawkish comments could be intended to create additional pressure on financial markets before officials eventually bring the rate-hiking cycle to an end.

Meanwhile, interest-rate futures continue to indicate expectations of a 25-basis-point increase in December and another in January, followed by a possible additional adjustment by April.

  • Related Posts

    Weak Demand Forces Roundhill to Scrap Solana and XRP Yield ETF Plans

    Roundhill has scrapped its plans to introduce two income-focused ETFs tied to Solana (SOL) and XRP, reflecting the limited appetite for complex cryptocurrency investment strategies compared with funds offering direct…

    Continue reading
    Jensen Huang’s Potential Exit: What a Rene Haas Takeover Could Mean for Crypto

    Nvidia may be considering a major leadership change, with Rene Haas reportedly emerging as a possible candidate to replace Jensen Huang as CEO. Haas has gained recognition for expanding Arm’s…

    Continue reading