
Cardano’s community has voted down Toto Finance’s proposal to withdraw 22 million ADA from the network’s treasury to purchase physical copper, bringing the initiative to an end after the voting period closed on Sunday. The proposal received approximately 20 million ADA in favor, while none of the blockchain’s seven constitutional committee members supported it.
The decision reflects strong resistance to using Cardano’s treasury for a commodity investment rather than conventional ecosystem development. Opposition outweighed supporting votes by more than 140 times, with roughly 2.86 billion ADA cast against the request and another 131 million ADA recorded as a no-confidence vote.
Cardano’s governance system assigns voting power based on the amount of ADA held or delegated by participants. Consequently, the final tally showed that support for the proposal accounted for less than 1% of the stake that took part in the vote.
Toto Finance, which develops blockchain tokens backed by physical commodities, had sought approximately $5 million worth of ADA for its copper acquisition strategy. The company planned to allocate around two-thirds of the funds toward purchasing COMEX-grade copper and storing it near New Orleans.
Under the proposed arrangement, the physical copper would have been represented on-chain through tokens issued at a ratio of one token per pound. Toto intended to hold the commodity for 18 to 24 months before selling it, with the proceeds scheduled to return to Cardano’s treasury within three years.
The voting outcome also revealed little institutional support within Cardano’s governance structure. Of the seven constitutional committee members, three voted against the request and four abstained or did not participate. The committee evaluates whether governance proposals comply with the network’s constitution.
Cardano requires treasury withdrawal proposals to secure approval from at least 67% of the active voting stake. Toto’s request fell far short of that threshold, despite attracting around 20 million ADA in affirmative votes.
Copper Investment Faced Significant Financial Hurdles
The proposed purchase carried considerable price risk for Cardano’s treasury. According to CoinDesk’s October analysis, copper would have needed to gain approximately 49% in value for the investment to recover the dollar value of the ADA spent, assuming the cryptocurrency’s price remained unchanged.
The proposal also outlined payments to Toto Finance that could have reached 3.36 million ADA, or roughly 15% of the requested treasury allocation. These payments included technology and management fees, transaction execution charges, and margins connected to storage and insurance invoices.
Toto Finance founder Monty Metzger had previously rejected the suggestion that the company would profit from the arrangement, telling CoinDesk: “Toto takes no profit from this proposal.”
Rejection Preserves Remaining Treasury Capacity
The vote’s outcome also prevents the copper initiative from consuming a substantial share of Cardano’s remaining treasury withdrawal allowance.
Cardano’s community had previously established a 500 million ADA cap on treasury withdrawals through approximately July 2027. By October 16, around 457.4 million ADA had already been committed, leaving limited room for further allocations.
Toto Finance’s 22 million ADA request would have accounted for more than half of the remaining capacity, making it one of the larger proposed uses of the available funds.
Toto Finance had not responded to CoinDesk’s questions by publication time, including whether it plans to revise the investment proposal or bring it back for another vote.





